Timing is everything — stretch keyframes to slow down or speed up an animation without redoing the whole thing.
Steps to stretch keyframes in time
Select your keyframes, then hold Alt (Windows) / Option (Mac) and drag the last keyframe left or right.

Dragging outward slows the animation down; dragging inward speeds it up.

Preview your comp to check the new timing and make sure it feels right.
One more thing
For multiple layers, select all their keyframes and use the same trick — everything scales in sync together, which saves tons of time.
Related how-tos
How to copy and paste keyframes in After Effects
How to use the graph editor in After Effects
How to use easing for smooth animation in After Effects
Need more help? Explore all our How-tos in one place.